The stick is not what shoots
Twenty men and twenty women, half of each group rated as skilled, took wrist shots and slap shots with three shafts of different construction and stiffness, over a force plate, filmed at high speed and clocked on radar. Puck velocity did not follow the stick type: it followed skill level and overall body strength. The authors even attribute the differences in shaft bending to the placement of the bottom hand, not to what the stick was made of.
Wu, Pearsall, Hodges et al., 2003, Sports Engineering 6, 31-39