AcademyThe RinkLog philosophy

Why no one gets left behind: the relative age effect

Progress, not pressure

Try Premium free for 7 days

No credit card required. The free plan stays free.

On this page
  1. What is the relative age effect in hockey?
  2. How many late-born players make it to junior?
  3. Why does the gap close among professionals?
  4. The growth spurt: why two 13-year-olds are not playing the same sport
  5. NHL players the draft did not see coming
  6. Why judging a U11 on a single season misleads
  7. How to read a young player’s progress against themselves
  8. Frequently asked questions

This page explains where the gap comes from, why the growth spurt amplifies it at the worst possible moment, and what a parent can actually do: stop reading a U11 season as a verdict, and start reading their kid’s progress against themselves.

What is the relative age effect in hockey?

In Canada, youth hockey age divisions are based on age as of December 31, as our page on youth hockey levels explains. A child born on January 2 and another born on December 30 therefore play on the same U9 team, almost a year apart. At that age, a year is more than 10% of their whole life. The older one is often taller, stronger and better coordinated, and looks “better” for reasons that have nothing to do with talent.

The foundational study is Canadian. In 1985, Roger Barnsley, Angus Thompson and Paula Barnsley sorted NHL, WHL and OHL players by birth month. They found a very strong linear relationship: January supplied the most players, and numbers declined month after month to the end of the year. Their conclusion, even then, was that potentially talented players were not reaching the level their ability would have allowed.

The mechanism feeds itself. The more mature child gets picked for the AA or AAA team, gets more ice, better coaches and more competition. A year later, they really are better, but partly because they were developed better. The younger one plays less, improves more slowly, and sometimes ends up believing they are “not cut out for it”.

How many late-born players make it to junior?

Forty years after Barnsley, the effect has not gone away. In 2023, Lemoyne, Trudeau and Grondin analyzed 7,399 players from fifteen junior and minor professional leagues during the 2021-22 season, plus 812 NHL players. Among junior and minor pro players, those born January to March hold 33% of spots, against 16% for those born October to December: twice as many.

The authors note the effect is stronger in Canadian leagues. In other words, the way we organize youth hockey, with early selection and elite teams from U11 on, produces this imbalance more strongly than elsewhere.

The data

Birth quarter of junior and minor professional players

January to March33%

The oldest in their age group

April to June29%
July to September22%
October to December16%

Up to eleven months younger

Across 7,399 players from fifteen leagues in 2021-22, those born early in the year hold twice as many spots as those born late. The difference is not talent, it is age.

Source: Lemoyne, J., Trudeau, F., et Grondin, S. (2023)

Why does the gap close among professionals?

The same study shows the effect fading at the top. In the NHL, the share of late-born players climbs back to 20%, and the statistical strength of the effect is clearly weaker than in junior. Better still: in junior, late-born players score as many points as the others despite playing fewer games, and in the NHL, at the 90th percentile, those born October to December post more points per 60 minutes than those born January to March.

The simplest explanation is this: a December-born player who survived ten years of unfavourable selections had to develop something other than size. Reading the play, decision speed, fine skills. When the older player’s physical edge fades in adulthood, those skills remain.

The flip side is harsh. A study by S. Lemez and colleagues, published in 2014 on 14,325 players aged 10 to 15 in the Ontario Minor Hockey Association, found dropout was highest among players born in the last two quarters of the year. Those who might have caught up never do if they leave the sport first. Keeping a kid in hockey literally means giving their curve time to rise.

Players by birth quarter, 2021-22 season
Birth quarterJunior and minor pro (7,399)NHL (812)
January to March33%31%
April to June29%27%
July to September22%22%
October to December16%20%

Swipe the table sideways to see every column.

The closer you get to the NHL, the more the share of late-born players rises: the gap of the early years was not measuring talent alone.

Source: Lemoyne, Trudeau and Grondin (2023), Table 3. Percentages rounded to the nearest unit.

Late-born players able to emerge in the NHL performed similarly and sometimes displayed better performance

Lemoyne, Trudeau et GrondinStudy of 7,399 junior and minor pro players and 812 NHL players, Journal of Human Kinetics, 2023Source

The growth spurt: why two 13-year-olds are not playing the same sport

Relative age is only half the problem. The other half is biological maturation: when a child goes through peak height velocity, the period when they grow fastest. A review published in 2025 places that peak between 9 and 15 in girls and between roughly 11 and a half and 17 in boys. Two boys born on the same day can therefore be several years apart physically.

In hockey, that difference often decides selection. L. B. Sherar and colleagues followed 281 players aged 14 and 15 at Saskatchewan provincial selection camps in 2003: those kept on the final team were taller, heavier and more advanced in maturation than the players cut. They were also more often born in the first half of the year.

Worse, growth itself temporarily scrambles the picture. The same 2025 review notes a passing awkwardness around peak growth: the kid who just gained eight centimetres sometimes skates worse than six months ago, while coordination catches up with the body. A parent who judges that season without context sees a regression where there is only a work in progress.

The chart below illustrates the idea: progress curves of players who bloom at different ages. They are illustrative, not taken from a real kid, but they show what the research describes: at 11, the order of the curves says almost nothing about their order at 18.

Three players, three curves

Slide the age and watch the ranking change. Nobody progresses at the same pace.

Playing levelU11U13U15U1891011121314151617

Who looks best?

  1. 1Alex, born in January
  2. 2Charlie, steady progress
  3. 3Sam, born in November

In U11, Alex looks like the most gifted. In reality, Alex mostly has a few months and a few inches of head start.

Illustrative curves, not real measurements: they follow the shape described by research on maturation and the relative age effect.

Try Premium free for 7 days

No credit card required. The free plan stays free.

team selectors appear to preferentially select early maturing male ice hockey players

Sherar, Baxter-Jones, Faulkner et RussellStudy of 281 players aged 14 and 15 at Saskatchewan selection camps, Journal of Sports Sciences, 2007Source

NHL players the draft did not see coming

If professional scouts regularly misjudge 18-year-olds, imagine the margin of error on a 10-year-old. Three well-known, verifiable examples show how badly an early projection can miss. None of them proves a given player “bloomed late” because of growth; they only show that a judgment made at one moment is not a destiny.

Pavel Datsyuk, 171st pick

Drafted by Detroit in the 6th round, 171st overall, in 1998. He went on to win two Stanley Cups (2002, 2008), three Selke Trophies and four Lady Byng Trophies, with 918 points in 953 games, before entering the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2024.

Joe Pavelski, 205th pick

Taken by San Jose in the 7th round, 205th overall, in 2003. People doubted his skating. He played 18 NHL seasons: 1,332 games, 476 goals and 1,068 points.

Martin St. Louis, never drafted

Passed over in the draft, largely because of his size (5 ft 8 in). He won the Stanley Cup and the Hart Trophy as most valuable player in 2004, then entered the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2018.

These are exceptions, and presenting them as a promise would be dishonest: most kids will never play in the NHL, and that is not the point. What they teach holds at every level, from recreational U9 to U15 AAA: the picture of any given season is a snapshot, not a film.

Why judging a U11 on a single season misleads

Hockey Canada says so in its own long-term player development framework: the model rests on the principle of doing the right thing for the player at the right moment in their development, and it lists among the system’s flaws the use of chronological age rather than developmental age. A U11 season is precisely chronological age. Four concrete reasons explain why it often lies.

  • Birth month: a child born in November faces teammates up to eleven months older, and the scoreboard never adjusts for it.
  • Maturation: peak growth can arrive years earlier or later from one child to the next, and it temporarily disrupts coordination.
  • Opportunity: ice time, line placement and a power play spot depend on the coach, not only on the player.
  • Small sample: twenty-five U11 games are too few to tell talent from luck, especially for goals, which are rare and very noisy.

That is also why statistics in initiation hockey are not for ranking, but for noticing what is improving, as our page on initiation hockey statistics explains. And if you are still hesitating to measure anything at all for fear of piling on, start with does tracking their stats put pressure on them.

Do the right thing for the player at the right moment in their development.

Hockey CanadaFirst principle of the long-term player development frameworktranslated from FrenchSource

How to read a young player’s progress against themselves

This is where measurement becomes an act of fairness. A tournament ranking compares kids of different effective ages and crushes the younger ones. A personal curve asks only one question: is this player improving compared with themselves? It is the only comparison the relative age effect cannot distort, because the player is always exactly their own age.

In RinkLog, a player’s only opponent is their previous self. Progress charts show their shots, ice time or faceoffs game after game, and a trend arrow compares their latest games with the rest of their season. No ranking between teammates, no leaderboard. Four steps are enough to get something useful out of it.

  1. Step 1: Measure what they control

    Shots attempted, shifts, ice time, faceoffs, blocked shots, backchecks: these numbers depend on effort and often climb before points do.

  2. Step 2: Watch the trend, not the game

    A single evening means nothing. Compare the last five or ten games with the start of the season, never one game with another.

  3. Step 3: Compare seasons with each other

    The real curve reads from one year to the next. The U13 who has doubled their shots since U11 is improving, whatever their rank on the team.

  4. Step 4: Give it years, not months

    During peak growth, a plateau or a small dip is normal. Note it, do not judge it, and look at where the curve stands a year later.

The practical conclusion fits in one sentence: never draw a final conclusion from a season at 9, 10 or 11. Measure, encourage, and let the curve speak over several years. According to the research, late-born players who stay in the sport have every chance of catching up with the pack. The best thing adults can do is give them a reason to stay, which is the subject of progress, not pressure.

Your kid’s only opponent is last year’s version of themselves. Follow their curve, not the standings. Permanent free plan, no card.

Try Premium free for 7 days

No credit card required. The free plan stays free.

Frequently asked questions

My child was born in December, are they at a disadvantage in hockey?

Statistically, yes, especially in early-year selections: they face teammates up to eleven months older. But research also shows the gap closes with age, and late-born players who stay in the sport produce as much as the others in junior and in the NHL. The real risk is not their birth month, it is quitting before their curve rises.

At what age do hockey players hit their growth spurt?

There is no single age. According to a 2025 review, peak growth usually occurs between 9 and 15 in girls and between roughly 11 and a half and 17 in boys. Two kids of the same age can therefore be years apart, and a passing awkwardness around that peak is normal.

My kid got cut from AA at 10, is it over?

No. A selection at 10 mostly measures size, maturity and birth month, and research on Canadian hockey shows those gaps fade over time. What matters now is that they keep enjoying the game and improving against themselves. The guide to preparing for tryouts explains how to turn a cut into concrete goals.

Do late-born players really do better in the NHL?

Not all of them, and caution is warranted. The study by Lemoyne and colleagues (2023) mainly shows they perform at least as well. The only clear edge observed is in points per 60 minutes among top players (90th percentile). The useful message is not “born late is better”, it is “born late is not a ceiling”.

How do I track my child’s progress without comparing them to others?

By comparing their recent games with the start of their season, and their seasons with each other. Favour the stats they control (shots, shifts, ice time, faceoffs) and read them as trends rather than game by game. In RinkLog, the charts and the trend arrow do exactly that, with no ranking between teammates.

References

Every number on this page comes from one of these sources. The links lead to the original text. Quotes from French-language sources are our own translations.

  1. Lemoyne, J., Trudeau, F., et Grondin, S. (2023)

    The Relative Age Effect in Ice Hockey: Analysis of Its Presence, Its Fading and of a Reversal Effect among Junior and Professional Leagues

    Journal of Human Kinetics, 87, 119 à 131

    7,399 players from fifteen junior and minor professional leagues and 812 NHL players, 2021-22 season. Source of the chart and table, and of the reversal among late-born players.

    Read it
  2. Barnsley, R. H., Thompson, A. H., et Barnsley, P. E. (1985)

    Hockey success and birthdate: The relative age effect

    CAHPER Journal, 51

    The foundational study, on the NHL, WHL and OHL: a very strong linear relationship between birth month and the share of players.

    Read it
  3. Lemez, S., Baker, J., Horton, S., Wattie, N., et Weir, P. (2014)

    Examining the relationship between relative age, competition level, and dropout rates in male youth ice-hockey players

    Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 24(6), 935 à 942

    14,325 players aged 10 to 15 in the Ontario Minor Hockey Association: dropout is highest among players born in the last two quarters.

    Read it
  4. Sherar, L. B., Baxter-Jones, A. D., Faulkner, R. A., et Russell, K. W. (2007)

    Do physical maturity and birth date predict talent in male youth ice hockey players?

    Journal of Sports Sciences, 25(8), 879 à 886

    281 players aged 14 and 15 at Saskatchewan provincial camps in 2003: the players selected were taller, heavier and more mature.

    Read it
  5. Retzepis, N.-O., Avloniti, A., Kokkotis, C., et coll. (2025)

    The Effect of Peak Height Velocity on Strength and Power Development of Young Athletes: A Scoping Review

    Journal of Functional Morphology and Kinesiology, 10(2), 168

    Scoping review: age of peak height velocity in girls and boys, and passing awkwardness around that peak.

    Read it
  6. Hockey Canada

    Cadre pour la programmation du développement à long terme du joueur

    Programmes de développement de Hockey Canada (document en français)

    The model’s principles, including doing the right thing for the player at the right moment of their development, and its criticism of chronological age as a planning basis. Read in French only.

    Read it
  7. Detroit Red Wings (NHL.com) (2024)

    Pavel Datsyuk elected to Hockey Hall of Fame Class of 2024

    NHL.com

    Pavel Datsyuk’s draft position, trophies and career statistics.

    Read it
  8. San Jose Sharks (NHL.com)

    Joe Pavelski silenced doubters on way to U.S. Hockey Hall of Fame

    NHL.com

    Joe Pavelski’s draft position, doubts about his skating and career statistics.

    Read it
  9. Bay News 9 (2018)

    Lightning great Martin St. Louis makes NHL Hall of Fame

    baynews9.com

    Martin St. Louis: undrafted largely because of his size, Hart Trophy and Stanley Cup in 2004, Hall of Fame in 2018.

    Read it

The free plan lets you create a player and track their games with no credit card.

Create my free account

On the same topic

RinkLog

RinkLog

Track your player's hockey stats live from the stands

Check it out on Product Hunt →