No credit card required. The free plan stays free.
On this page
- Why points are not enough to evaluate a player
- What do minor hockey association evaluation grids look at?
- Skating, hockey sense, compete, attitude: how to observe them
- Stats as evidence, not as a grade
- A five-step method to evaluate a player over a season
- Preparing for tryouts without measuring yourself against others
- Frequently asked questions
This page is for parents who want to understand how their child is evaluated, and for volunteer coaches who have to evaluate without a ready-made grid. It relies on the evaluation and selection guide Hockey Canada publishes for minor hockey associations, and it ends with preparing for tryouts.
Why points are not enough to evaluate a player
Points mostly reward the ice time received and the role assigned. A first-line player on the power play will have more points than a third-line penalty killer, without necessarily being better. Points also ignore all work without the puck: a backcheck, a defensive-zone faceoff won, a shot blocked late in the game leave no trace in the column.
Then there is luck. Over a three-game tournament, a lucky bounce or a red-hot opposing goaltender is enough to change the sheet. The classic mistake is judging a player off a single tournament scoresheet: three games say almost nothing, while twenty games measured with the same definitions start to draw a reliable picture.
Finally, points say nothing about what makes a young player improve: the quality of his skating, his reading of the game, how he reacts to a mistake. That is why associations evaluate skills and behaviours first, and why the best evaluations use stats to check, not to decide. The page why goals are not everything develops this idea.
What do minor hockey association evaluation grids look at?
Hockey Canada's evaluation and selection guide offers associations a common grid for forwards and defensemen, rated from 1 (poor) to 5 (outstanding). It covers skating, passing, puck control, shooting, checking, game understanding, offensive and defensive 1-on-1, and faceoffs. A second page covers character: fitness, determination, coachability, concentration, mental toughness, discipline, team play and leadership.
The guide insists on transparency: criteria should be published so parents know what the evaluation rests on, and every player should get at least two sessions before being released. It recommends that evaluators know only the pinny number, not the name, and that players not wear elite team jerseys, which can sway an evaluator without him realizing it.
On the Hockey Québec side, we did not find a single provincial grid published online: each association and region publishes its own criteria and weighting, often drawn from the same framework. The right move is to ask your association for its evaluation document before camp. If none exists, the Hockey Canada grid summarized below is a solid starting point.
| Criterion | What the evaluator watches | What a stat can support |
|---|---|---|
| Skating | Acceleration, speed, agility, balance, crossovers, pivots, stopping both ways | Very little: skating is observed, not counted |
| Passing and puck control | Accuracy, backhand reception, head up, protection in tight space | Assists, giveaways |
| Shooting | Power, accuracy, quick release, shot selection | Shots on goal, missed shots, goals |
| Game understanding | Positioning, support of the puck carrier, read and react, communication | On-ice chances for and against, takeaways |
| Checking and defensive 1-on-1 | Angling, body position, gap control, net-front play | Hits, blocked shots, puck battles won |
| Faceoffs | Win or lose the draw, tie up the opponent, know responsibilities | Faceoffs won and lost |
| Character and attitude | Determination, coachability, discipline, team play, accepts his role | Backchecks (counted on effort), penalty minutes |
Swipe the table sideways to see every column.
No stat evaluates any of these lines on its own. It confirms or qualifies what the eye has seen.
Criteria summarized from Hockey Canada's evaluation and selection guide for forwards and defensemen. The right-hand column is our addition, not the guide's.
These criteria must be clearly defined, objectively assessed and justifiable.
Skating, hockey sense, compete, attitude: how to observe them
Four qualities appear in every grid, and none can be read on a scoresheet. They are observed in play, ideally over several sessions, and with precise questions rather than a general impression. The Hockey Canada guide asks one question that sums up the whole scrimmage: does the player take part in the play, and does he influence the outcome?
Skating
The base of everything. The guide asks whether the player turns and stops both ways, keeps his knees bent and head up, and keeps up with the play. With younger players, it often weighs the most.
Hockey sense
Getting to the right spot, supporting the puck carrier, communicating, reading and reacting. It shows most in small spaces (2-on-2, 3-on-3), where every decision counts.
Compete level
Coming back hard, winning battles, not giving up on a shift. The guide speaks of a constant desire to excel, in practice as in games.
Attitude
The guide offers concrete indicators: following instructions, handling criticism and learning from mistakes, respecting coaches, officials and opponents, showing leadership.
The guide also notes that the weight of the scrimmage grows with age: with younger players, the evaluation focuses on skills; with older players, game play weighs more. The figure below shows its suggested weighting.
The data
The weight of the scrimmage in the evaluation, by category
plus 25% tactics
plus 20% tactics
Share of the evaluation given to the scrimmage in Hockey Canada's suggested plan (the rest goes to skills and, from U15, to tactics). The older the player, the more game play counts.
Source: Hockey Canada
Stats as evidence, not as a grade
An on-ice evaluation is a snapshot: a few sessions, under pressure, in front of strangers. A season of stats is a film. It does not replace the evaluator's eye, but it lets you check an impression. "He never comes back" can be checked by counting backchecks; "he loses the puck a lot" can be checked by counting giveaways. Sometimes the impression holds, sometimes it falls apart.
For a stat to serve as evidence, it has to follow a few rules. It must be put in context (ice time, role, power play or penalty kill). It must cover enough games for luck to fade. It must be recorded with the same definitions from one game to the next. And it must be read as a trend: the last ten games compared with the first ten say more than the season total.
Above all, a stat must never become a grade that sums up a young player. Reducing a twelve-year-old to a number forgets everything the Hockey Canada grid observes that cannot be counted. It is also the surest way to teach him to play for the sheet instead of for the team. RinkLog is built on that principle: it makes visible what the player did, game after game, and the only opponent it shows him is the previous version of himself.
- Production: points per game, and per ice time when it is known
- Impact: chances for and against and +/-, read as trends, never off one game
- Volume: shots and attempts, the engine that comes before points
- Context: ice time, role, power play and penalty kill
- Trajectory: the last ten games compared with the first ten
No credit card required. The free plan stays free.
A five-step method to evaluate a player over a season
Whether you are a parent or a coach, the same approach works. It starts from the criteria, goes through observation and numbers, and always comes back to the player himself rather than to his teammates.
Step 1: Set the criteria
Start from your association's grid or Hockey Canada's, and pick three or four areas suited to the age and position.
Step 2: Pick the numbers that support them
For each measurable area, one or two stats: turnovers for reliability, backchecks for effort, faceoffs for a center.
Step 3: Observe over several games
Record the same things, the same way, for at least five games before drawing any conclusion.
Step 4: Read the trend
Compare blocks of games with each other: what rises, what drops, what stays flat. Ignore the single game.
Step 5: Turn it into a goal, not a verdict
Draw one or two concrete goals from it with the young player, and measure again in a month.
Preparing for tryouts without measuring yourself against others
A tryout is a short and imperfect measurement, and research confirms it. A review by Till and Baker (2020) concludes that the accuracy of talent identification and selection is poor, and that it drops further when selection happens at younger ages. The same authors point out that athletes who are older within their cohort and those who mature earlier get more selection opportunities.
Preparing for tryouts is therefore not about comparing yourself with other kids, but about arriving at your best: well rested, gear ready, knowing what the association evaluates. Season stats then serve one precise purpose: reminding the young player, with facts, of what he does well. A winger who knows he won most of his puck battles this winter arrives at camp with a confidence that does not depend on a single session.
And if the result is not the one hoped for, the Hockey Canada guide recommends meeting each released player one on one, covering strengths and areas to work on. That is the best possible follow-up: turning a decision into two or three measurable goals. Our guide on preparing for tryouts covers preparation in detail, and confidence comes from evidence explains how to lean on facts rather than encouragement.
The current evidence evaluating talent identification and selection accuracy suggests poor validity, which decreases further when conducted at younger ages.
A fair evaluation rests on facts recorded game after game. Permanent free plan, no card required.
No credit card required. The free plan stays free.
Frequently asked questions
What are players evaluated on in minor hockey?
In the Hockey Canada grid: skating, passing, puck control, shooting, checking, game understanding, offensive and defensive 1-on-1, faceoffs, and a character page (determination, discipline, team play, leadership). Each association can adapt the criteria and their weight: ask for its document before camp.
Do stats count in a tryout evaluation?
Rarely in a direct way: evaluators observe skills and behaviours during the sessions. Season stats mostly serve the player and his family, to know what he does well and what is improving, and the coach who already knows him, to check an impression.
How do you evaluate a hockey player who doesn't score much?
On the grid criteria (skating, hockey sense, checking, attitude) and on the stats that describe his role: backchecks, takeaways, blocked shots, faceoffs, penalty kill time. A reliable defensive player can have an excellent season with few points.
How many sessions does it take to evaluate a player fairly?
The Hockey Canada guide recommends at least two sessions per player before any release, and a sample plan of five sessions per category. For in-season tracking, allow at least five games recorded the same way before drawing a conclusion.
My child was cut: what should we do with that evaluation?
Ask for specific feedback on his strengths and areas to work on, as Hockey Canada recommends, then turn it into two measurable goals for the season. Research shows selection predicts the future poorly in young athletes: a cut is information, not a verdict on his potential.
References
Every number on this page comes from one of these sources. The links lead to the original text.
Hockey Canada
Guide de développement du hockey mineur : évaluation et sélection des joueurs / Minor Hockey Development Guide: Player Evaluation and Selection
Hockey Canada, programme des associations de hockey mineur
1-to-5 grid for forwards and defensemen, character page, attitude indicators, at least two sessions per player, anonymous pinnies, skills and scrimmage weighting by category, one-on-one meetings with released players. English version: mha-player-evaluation-guide-e.pdf.
Read itTill, K., et Baker, J. (2020)
Challenges and [Possible] Solutions to Optimizing Talent Identification and Development in Sport
Frontiers in Psychology, 11, 664
Review on the poor predictive validity of selection, which worsens at younger ages, and on the advantage of athletes who are older in their cohort and earlier maturing.
Read it
The free plan lets you create a player and track their games with no credit card.
Create my free accountOn the same topic
- How do you prepare for hockey tryouts?What an evaluator sees in three sessions, why simple play looks better, and how to prepare for a tryout on facts rather than impressions.
- Why goals are not everythingStay-at-home defensemen, 200-foot forwards, energy lines, penalty killers: what a player who does not score actually does, and the stats that prove it.
- Understanding roles in hockeyEvery hockey role in one table: center, winger, 200-foot forward, energy line, defensemen, goalie. What each one brings and how to measure it.
- How do you rebuild a young player's confidence?A kid on a pointless streak thinks they are playing badly, and nothing proves otherwise. Why confidence built on facts lasts longer than praise.
- M7 to M18: every labelEvery hockey age group in one table: U7 to U21 (Canada), 6U to 18U (USA), M7 to M18 (Quebec), Mite to Midget, France, Switzerland, Sweden, IIHF. Find your child’s label.

