No credit card required. The free plan stays free.
On this page
- Measuring or judging: what is the difference?
- Why talk about process rather than talent?
- Instead of saying... say: the sentences that change everything
- What a parent shows with numbers, and what they keep quiet
- When and how to look at the numbers together
- From numbers to confidence: learning to read yourself
- Frequently asked questions
A number is neither kind nor cruel. “Three shots” is a description. “Only three shots” is already a judgment, and “you never shoot” is another, heavier one. The whole method lies in that nuance: keep the number and drop the adjective.
Measuring or judging: what is the difference?
Measuring means answering the question “what happened?”. Six shifts, four shots, two backchecks, 55% of faceoffs won. Judging means answering a different question: “what does that say about you?”. Good player, bad game, not enough character. The first question can be checked; the second can only be endured.
The difference matters because a kid does not hear the two the same way. A measurement can be discussed, disputed, understood: “yeah, I shot less, I was playing defence tonight”. A judgment stamps itself onto identity. The same number can serve both, and the sentence around it decides. “You shot four times” informs. “You only shot four times, again” condemns.
Measuring without judging does not mean finding everything wonderful. A bad game is still a bad game, and denying it mostly teaches the kid to stop believing what you say. It means describing what happened without turning it into a verdict on the person, and always putting the number back in its trend.
Why talk about process rather than talent?
Because praise for talent carries a hidden cost. In 1998, Claudia Mueller and Carol Dweck of Columbia University published six studies with fifth graders. Those praised for their intelligence cared more about looking good than about learning. After a failure, they persisted less, enjoyed the task less, performed worse and blamed the failure on low ability more than children praised for their effort. These studies involved school tasks, not sport, but the mechanism is easy to recognize at the rink.
“You are a natural scorer” feels like a gift. The day the goals stop coming, it turns into an accusation: if I do not score, I am not that scorer. “You parked yourself in front of the net all game” does not wear out the same way, because it describes something the kid can do again tomorrow, whether they score or not.
Sport psychology lands in the same place. Smoll and Smith’s mastery approach asked coaches to increase four behaviours: positive reinforcement, encouragement right after a mistake, corrections given in a positive way, and sound technical instruction. And a review of 104 studies consistently links the climate that values personal improvement with more motivation and self-esteem. Process-centred feedback is that climate translated into everyday words.
six studies demonstrated that praise for intelligence had more negative consequences for students' achievement motivation than praise for effort
Instead of saying... say: the sentences that change everything
Here are situations every youth hockey parent will recognize, with the sentence that judges and the one that measures. Both talk about the same game. Only the second leaves the kid something to work on, and a reason to come back and talk to you about it.
| Situation | Instead of saying | Say instead |
|---|---|---|
| No points tonight | “Zero points again?” | “You took five shots. Which one was your best?” |
| A teammate scored three goals | “Your friend scored three.” | “Your backchecks helped the team all night.” |
| A hat trick | “You’re a born scorer!” | “You got to the front of the net every shift.” |
| Bad faceoffs | “You lose every one.” | “Your faceoffs have been climbing for a month. Did you change something?” |
| Little ice time | “The coach doesn’t trust you.” | “Your shifts were short and intense. That’s exactly right.” |
| A costly penalty | “You made us lose.” | “What would you do differently next time?” |
| A defenceman with no points | “You need to produce more.” | “Three blocked shots and a +1. That’s your job, and you did it.” |
Swipe the table sideways to see every column.
The sentence that measures describes an action the kid can repeat. The sentence that judges describes a person they cannot change.
Examples written by RinkLog from the principles of process-centred feedback. Faceoffs do not exist in ringette: adapt the statistic to the sport.
What a parent shows with numbers, and what they keep quiet
The selection rule is simple: show what compares the kid with themselves, and keep quiet what compares them with others. Also show the stats that depend on them (shots attempted, shifts, backchecks, blocked shots, faceoffs), because they describe the work that precedes goals and often climb before points do. That is the subject of why goals are not everything.
Keep quiet about the isolated bad game, not to hide it, but because a single game is too small a sample to say anything. Over five or ten games, it becomes what it is: a low point on a curve. And always keep quiet about the named teammate, even when the comparison is flattering, because it teaches the kid that their worth depends on their rank.
- Show: the 5-game trend, personal records broken, the effort stat that is climbing
- Keep quiet: comparisons with a named teammate, the isolated bad game, rankings
- Say: “your shots have been climbing for a month, can you feel it?” or “a new shifts record!”
- Avoid: “only one goal?”, “your friend scored three”, “you need to produce more”
- Let the kid ask: the day they want to see their own curves, you have won
When and how to look at the numbers together
The best moment is a day or two after the game, at home, when nothing is at stake. The best format is short: five minutes, not a meeting. Four steps, in order, are enough.
Step 1: Wait for the emotion to settle
Never in the car, never on the night of a loss. A number raised in the heat of the moment is heard as a judgment, even when it is good.
Step 2: Open with the trend
Start with the curve across several games, not the last line. “Look at your shots since October” frames everything else.
Step 3: Pick a single number
The one that is climbing, or the one that contradicts what the kid believes about their game. Just one. A full dashboard feels like a report card.
Step 4: End with a question
“Can you feel it too?”, “What did you change?”. Let them draw the conclusion. If they do not want to talk about it, that is an answer too.
This kind of conversation is what RinkLog exists for. The parent logs events live from the stands, and the app turns them into progress charts, game after game, with a trend arrow comparing the latest games with the rest of the season. There is no ranking between players: the kid’s only opponent is their previous self.
a conception of success as giving maximum effort and becoming the best one can be, rather than an emphasis on winning or outperforming others
No credit card required. The free plan stays free.
From numbers to confidence: learning to read yourself
The end goal is not for the parent to know the kid’s numbers: it is for the kid to learn to read their own. A teenager who can say “my faceoff percentage is climbing because I changed my stance” has developed something more precious than any statistic: the ability to self-evaluate without self-destructing. It is a life skill disguised as a hockey board.
That is also where solid confidence is born. Confidence built on compliments collapses at the first pointless streak; confidence built on facts they read themselves holds, because it rests on something checkable. Two pages extend this one: confidence comes from evidence, for the kid who doubts themselves, and does tracking their stats put pressure on them, for the parent who is still hesitating. And to understand why the curve matters more than the rank, especially before adolescence, read every player has their curve.
Keep the number, drop the adjective. Curves to look at together, cold. Permanent free plan, no card.
No credit card required. The free plan stays free.
Frequently asked questions
What should I say to my child after a bad hockey game?
That night, very little: one sentence that acknowledges the emotion is enough, something like “that was a rough night”. The numbers wait a day or two. Then, open with the trend of recent games rather than that one game, and ask a question rather than deliver a verdict.
Should you show a young player their statistics?
Yes, if they compare them with themselves and cover what they control. One well-chosen number, presented as a trend, helps a kid see they are improving. A full dashboard or a comparison with a teammate does the opposite.
Is praising my child for their talent a bad idea?
It is not a problem once in a while, but a classic study by Mueller and Dweck (1998), on school tasks, found that praise for intelligence left children more fragile after failure than praise for effort. In hockey, prefer describing what they did (“you got to the front of the net”) over what they are (“you’re a born scorer”).
How do you talk stats with a defenceman who does not score?
By talking about the stats of their role: blocked shots, backchecks, takeaways, +/-, shorthanded ice time. Those are the numbers that describe their job. Our page on hockey roles details what each position brings beyond points.
My kid does not want to see their stats. What should I do?
Respect the choice. Numbers are a tool for them, not an obligation. Keep tracking if it helps you notice their progress, and save them for the day they ask to see their own curves. That day often comes when nobody pushes.
References
Every number on this page comes from one of these sources. The links lead to the original text.
Mueller, C. M., et Dweck, C. S. (1998)
Praise for Intelligence Can Undermine Children's Motivation and Performance
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75(1), 33 à 52
Six studies with fifth graders, on school tasks rather than sport. Praise for effort better protects persistence after failure.
Read itSmoll, F. L., Smith, R. E., et Cumming, S. P. (2007)
Effects of Coach and Parent Training on Performance Anxiety in Young Athletes: A Systemic Approach
Journal of Youth Development, 2(1)
Mastery Approach to Coaching guidelines: positive reinforcement, encouragement after mistakes, positive correction, technical instruction.
Read itHarwood, C. G., Keegan, R. J., Smith, J. M. J., et Raine, A. S. (2015)
A systematic review of the intrapersonal correlates of motivational climate perceptions in sport and physical activity
Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 18, 9 à 25
104 studies: the mastery climate is consistently associated with perceived competence, self-esteem and intrinsic motivation.
Read it
The free plan lets you create a player and track their games with no credit card.
Create my free accountOn the same topic
- What do you say to your kid in the car after the game?The most important and most botched moment in youth hockey. The sentence to drop, the questions that open a kid up, and why numbers can wait.
- How do you rebuild a young player's confidence?A kid on a pointless streak thinks they are playing badly, and nothing proves otherwise. Why confidence built on facts lasts longer than praise.
- Progress, not pressureMastery climate versus ego climate, youth sport dropout, the parent’s role: what research says, and how to talk statistics without adding pressure.
- Why no one gets left behind: the relative age effectThe relative age effect and the growth spurt distort youth hockey. What Canadian studies show, and how to read your own kid’s curve instead.
- Does tracking their stats put pressure on them?The real question for a hesitant parent: is measuring judging? What tracking changes for a young player, and the three rules that keep pressure away.

